Build Your Own Box of Muffins

In-Store Only
SKU
820

Create your own box of muffins! First select whether you want boxes of 4 or boxes of 6, then choose from any of our varieties to make your perfect combination, or select our Best Sellers option.

 
This Item is Only Available in Store

Please order by 10am ET to pick up your order next day.

 

  • Best Seller

Create your own box of muffins! First select whether you want boxes of 4 or boxes of 6, then choose from any of our varieties to make your perfect combination, or select our Best Sellers option.

Our decadent muffins are intended to be enjoyed upon receipt. But in the event that you have to delay your enjoyment, they can be refrigerated for 1-2 days until you’re ready to dig in. If you’d like to prolong the life of your muffins, they can be individually wrapped in plastic wrap, and then sealed tight in a freezer safe container. Muffins can be kept frozen for approximately 2 weeks, and take about 1 - 2 hours to thaw.

This product is only available in store.

Ingredients vary based on varieties chosen. Please consult individual muffin pages for full ingredient lists.

Allergen Information: Our products are produced in a facility containing milk, soy, nuts, nut products and gluten. Products may contain any of these items.

Select Varieties
  • These cookies come undecorated so you can make them your own! This girl stands 5 inches tall, and comes individually wrapped.

    Best Sellers
  • Blueberry Muffin

    Loaded with dozens of fresh Maine blueberries, and baked to perfection

  • Chocolate Chip Muffin

    Packed with mini chocolate chips, topped with crumbs and granulated sugar

  • Raspberry Blueberry Muffin

    Local raspberries and blueberries combine in this perfectly sweet and sour muffin

  • Strawberry Shortcake Muffin

    Yellow cake is filled with fresh cup strawberries and whipped crème. One of our best sellers!

  • Chocolate Raspberry Muffin

    Chocolate cake muffin filled with local raspberries, whipped crème, chocolate shavings, and chocoalte drizzle.

  • Lemon Poppy Seed Muffin

    A refreshing lemon muffin, scattered with poppy seeds, then filled with gooey lemon. Finished off with powdered sugar

  • Banana Crème Muffin

    Yellow cake is filled with fresh cut bananas, banana crème, and Heath Bar toffee crunch. Finished with a chocolate drizzle and powdered sugar

  • Boston Kreme Muffin

    A vanilla muffin filled with Bavarian cremem and finished with our homemade chocolate icing

  • Banana Walnut Muffin

    Packed with banana and walnut, and finished off with a crumb topping

  • Gingerbread Muffin

    Our best selling signature muffin! Filled with a swirl of cream cheese icing, and topped with powdered sugar

  • Corn Muffin

    A buttery, delicious breakfast favorite

  • Cranberry Walnut Muffin

    Local cranberries and walnuts pack this delicious muffin, topped with a bit of granulated sugar

  • Orange Almond Muffin

    Mandarin oranges and almond slivers pack this unexpected delight. Topped with powedered sugar and slivered almonds

  • Honey Raisin Bran Muffin

    A classic morning choice with plump raisins, and a bit of honey

  • Coffee Cake Muffin

    Filled with cinnamon schmear and topped with a chunky cinnamon crumble

  • Apple n' Spice Muffin

    Cinnamon base, loaded with chunks of real apples

  • Carrot Muffin with Icing

    Filled with fresh shredded carrots, walnuts, raisins, coconut and pineapple. It's finished off with our renowned white cream cheese icing.

  • Carrot Muffin without Icing
  • Pumpkin Raisin Muffin with Icing

    An extra moist muffin filled with fresh, plump raisins and topped off with our light orange colored cream cheese icing (optional).

  • Pumpkin Raisin Muffin without Icing

    An extra moist muffin filled with fresh, plump raisins and topped off with our light orange colored cream cheese icing (optional).

* Required Fields